Yeah, I probably should have asked that question first, before diving into two areas I need help with:

Here are the unedited student answers:

There’s lots here to return to tomorrow. I also worry about the schedule — how do we help students use as much of time as wisely as they can — and how do we not punish the students who are on-time with discussions that may or may not apply to them. In other words, the folks who understand that the culture supports the work don’t necessarily benefit by constantly reviewing how the culture supports the work.

Before we ate — thanks to everyone who brought food and every parent who prepared food — we gave thanks. On a piece of paper folded like a greeting card, we drew a picture of ourselves and listed all we’re thankful for. Then we began to pass and each person at the table had to write why they were thankful for each other person by writing within their card. Twenty two people at the table…it took awhile.

Then we passed to the person to our right who had to share just ONE thing that was written.

Yeah, I know I like the paper-based activities, but I’d point out that only one of these cards was left behind, that all of them stayed with the students. The talk meant something — you could feel the l*ve around the table — but the cards definitely got kept.

We had a terrific opening conversation this morning as kids started to consider ideas of accountability. We had started this earlier in the quarter but as with most things, you need to deal with it again and again.

KS led the discussion effectively.

I had two things that I wanted to get on their radar: one, how do social pressures affect ideas of accountability? In other words, how do we manage this one-on-one, in small groups, and as a large group? Two, how do we deal with situations when there’s no dissonance as a student talks about their work? In other words, when a student holds up a crap project and claims that it is amazing, how do we help puncture that illusion/delusion?

Some notes from their conversation:
It’s hard to hold people accountable when:
MH: ou don’t know them or the their work; when it doesn’t affect you.
AH: you’ve never done that work before
TC: they’re upset or angry
VG: people won’t reflect honestly; when it’s subtle (big is easier than small)
IP: they don’t accept responsibility

It’s easy to hold people accountable when:
DD: you have proof
VG: you share the same goals
MT: you focus on their goals
VG: you know their situation
KS: you’re aware of their (unique) situation.

Favorite line: We’re doing complex projects so it’s not always clear what good work is.

This is the text of the letter I sent to students and their parents at the end of first quarter. It’s an attempt to offer broad feedback across the entire range of projects so I don’t have to write the same thing over and over. At the end, I add a page for comment specific to students.

November 4, 2016

Dear family and friends,

What a great first quarter! Students: I hope you’ve enjoyed your time in 101/201 as much as I have. Parents: I hope your students have relayed some of the exciting work we’ve done together as well as the work they’re planning on doing second quarter. This letter is both a summary of the work we’ve done as well as some general recommendations for all students about how they can improve their final products and their work processes.

Our first project — the What’s Out There project — asked students to identify a community organization that they might work with in the future or a group that has served their area of Philadelphia. The best of these written projects can be found on the website, as I’ve slowly started posting the ones edited enough to be public. I want this website to become a resource for other students and staff in the coming years.

Some of the lessons I hope that students took from this project: one, writing for project work is something that ought to occur with a public purpose in mind. In this case, you were trying to share your work with other students and community members. As such, having clean, clear prose that’s accessible is very important. Second, while you are writing, you want to constantly be thinking about the intention of your final piece. Much of school is taken up with writing for no real purpose (think book reports that no one EVER reads again). Similarly, your research should be guided this way: why am I reading this piece? How will it help me? Many of you still go to a website (usually the first google result) and assume that because it popped up, the information it contains is worthwhile to your project. The more you critically read things, the better your project. I hope that these lessons from the project continue throughout the year.

Our second project — the Pallet Project/How we work piece — was designed to get you working in small groups and doing some building. The best of these projects were pretty stunning, particularly the nightstand/charging piece and the fish tank/plant stand. For those of you whose projects were not finished or partially finished, I hope you can ask yourself what happened. And as you answer, I hope you think about what your own role is and move past simple ideas like “I need to be more focused” or “our group had problems”. I’d also ask you think about how the three components might relate to each other — the eventual piece, the design portfolio, and the instructable — and what you can learn from this process. Some groups had group issues that appear to be ongoing. The lessons there seem obvious to me: is it possible to split the work up and then not talk to each other again?

Our third project represents something all of you earned from doing the Gateway project: the opportunity to design your own project for second quarter. We’ve been battling to get this done — no thanks to SEPTA — and I hope that each of you are proud of your work. The major thing to think about when you are designing your own piece is to make sure that you have a project you love and care deeply about. The work on these projects is going to get difficult! For example, you might love thinking about how body language reflects human intentions, but are you really ready to read a psychology textbook, study how scholars have addressed this question, and then formulate your own experiment? Or are you going to shut down the moment that the text and the project gets difficult? As each of you have designed these pieces yourselves, I’ve wondered about those of you who appear to be stuck already. What are the strategies you use? Remember that conceiving your own project is very, very hard work and so is also incredibly rewarding. For these projects to truly grow wings, you need to own them through and through: there’s only one teacher, but there are twenty other students and a city of 1.5 million souls who can help you move the work along. Use as many of them as you can.

Finally, in all of our spare time, we’ve taken on a series of hands-on projects. From safety videos to kitchen caddies to a cabinet for a local gardening center, you’ve all done some cool things. I know that this project has been an in-between project, one that we’ve not been able to focus big blocks of time on, but I still appreciate the effort being made by all of you. I look forward to seeing how these finish!

We’ve also read and written about a terrific book, The Boy Who Harnessed The Wind. Your short essays on whether you would recommend this book and how we as a school can use this book are reasonably well-done. As always, when you write about a text, spend less time explicitly summarizing (this happened and then this happened and then he did it) and more time explaining why the book matters. All of these essays, when ready, will be published on-line. For second quarter, we will have a book we will read, the curious incident of the dog in the night time, which is the Free Library’s One Book text. You will also have an individual book that you’ve selected, either with my help (what a terrific afternoon we had in the used bookstore) or on your own.

Remember that the point of book group is to do two things: one, build up stamina for reading; to succeed in college you will have to be able to read for extended periods of time without distraction. I hope that the various reading strategies we’ve talked about have helped with this, but try and carve 30, 60, 90 minutes a day when you are reading quietly, with no phone, and as few distractions as you can manage.

During the afternoons, all of you have attended CCP and Penn. Some of you have attended Drexel too! So far, we’ve been working as a large cohort but we will soon split to individual courses. Several thoughts: I want to applaud the majority of you who have understood and worked hard when presented with a lecture format, where the teacher or guest lecturer does most of the talking. This is a hard skill to develop but a critical one. You’re lucky — you attend a school where little of the time is taken up with a teacher upfront doing pretty much all of the talking. Much of college works differently and it’s important to realize that developing active listening skills will serve you very well. Second, remember that you are lucky to have a teacher, a principal, a counselor, and all sorts of adults who are constantly asking you how you are doing. All that will remain of us when you get to college is the echoes of our (annoying) voices and it will be up to you to figure out what to do. The more practice you get at maximizing these opportunities and tracking your own work, the better off you will be.

Several concluding ideas for you to think about. One, I hope all of you stay proud of the work you’ve done to create our advisory community. Every visitor who comes through remarks upon it. My favorite moment was when Daniel and Angeline were leading a tour and our group explained in such vivid detail what our school was about. To a serious muckety-muck from 440 who was absolutely blown away.

Two, I hope all of you think about how the work we’re doing this year connects to your future. This sort of project work helps you figure out how to keep yourself moving forward, even when it gets hard. More to the point, it helps you realize that life isn’t a series of on-off switches that you can throw when you feel like it. Consistent hard work ALWAYS pays off.

Three, I want all of you to think about the ways in which you seize control over your own work. What are the things you do to ensure that progress is being made? Some of this has to occur in school. It’s actually something I worry about: should I give less work time in school and spend more time creating activities that you can bring towards your own work? In other words, should I decrease the amount of time spent in whole group activities so that you can get work individually? What will be gained and what will be lost?

On a personal note, this quarter has been one of my favorite quarters in a long, long time. You are a fun yet serious group, a cohort committed to each other, and just fun to be around. Keep up the good work!

Affectionately and respectfully yours,

Clapper