A true war story is never moral. It does not instruct, nor encourage virtue, nor suggest proper models of human behavior, nor restrain men from doing the things men have always done. If a story seems moral, do not believe it. If at the end of a war story you feel uplifted, or if you feel that some small bit of rectitude has been salvaged from the larger waste, then you have been made the victim of a very old and terrible lie.

Cited in Robert Pinsky’s powerful review of Elizabeth Samet’s book in Sunday’s Times.

This article details an alternative to teacher certification programs, one that’s apparently based upon student teachers spending lots of time in the classroom.

Sounds like a great program.

My only question — why is it that most alternative routes to certification claim to be moving outside of the university setting but don’t actually eliminate university coursework? In other words, intern candidates may BEGIN teaching but they still have to complete university courses to get certified.

As a graduate of a teacher education program, and as a teacher educator, I do believe that there is great worth in a university based certification. But if we’re going to create alternative routes, let’s make sure they’re actually something different.

This sort of staff development school, where teachers certify new teachers, now that’d be something.

There’s a congratulatory article in today’s Inquirer detailing the ways in which a comprehensive high school has sought to increase graduation rates.

Great. Pat yourselves on the back. You’ve managed to have more children “pass” their classes.

But there’s no mention in the article of the content of these classes or whether or not students actually have a command of the content. While I’m certainly no advocate for standardized tests or attaching graduation to high-stakes exams, I think the press has a duty to question what’s happening in the classroom before writing such an article.

What’s the point of graduating kids who have proved that they can comply with requirements without assessing whether or not they’ve learned anything?

Reading this wonderful ethnography, First Year Out, and I’m struck by how surprised the author is by the student’s willingness to share their lives and world views with him.

My experience is that high school and college students are desperate for an adult to ask about their ideas, that they’re desperate for a chance to integrate their own ideas with the coursework. Some, perhaps even most, arrive ready to do so, but within a few weeks, it’s back to business as usual.

Every teacher has experienced the sudden electricity when every student in the room is thoroughly engaged. Unfortunately, it usually occurs by accident, when a student or the teacher somehow trips an invisible switch; only the most skilled practitioners can create this sort of engagement on purpose.

I wonder, for all those who teach multiple levels, how your preparation differs based on the composition of the class.

I teach high school students, undergraduates, advanced undergraduates and graduate students. But what I do for each class to prepare is quite similar. The major difference is that I have two or three back-up plans if I’m teaching high school, one or two if I’m dealing with undergrads, and I’m usually confident that my graduate classes will be over-planned.

Cool link here to a list of free music sites. I have used last.fm mostly so I can have album covers on my blog, but there’s some cool sites here.

Three starting points:
1. You must respect your students.
2. You must believe in your students.
3. You must trust your students.
3. Your intentions must be clear.

Five Statements
1. Be fair and consistent…but you don’t need to treat all students the same way.
2. Don’t make threats…but follow through if you do.
3. Discipline isn’t personal…but you are a human being.
4. The culture of the school may trump your efforts…but don’t give up.
5. Your whole class needs to reinforce the academic and “civic” culture of your room…but you can’t force them to do so.

“It feels great, man. It’s been a long time I don’t do something special like that. But I haven’t been right all year long. But when you don’t feel good and you still get hits, that’s when you know you are a bad man.”

John Edwards unveiled his education plan today.

From scratch, he wants to create a new university that will prepare one thousand teachers and offer advice on best practices to other schools of education. He uses Arthur Levine’s love letter to ed schools as justification.

The present rate of attrition will mean that this school will produce 500 teachers who stay more than five years in a tough district. That means that Philly will get five to seven of these folks — hooray.

So I’m teaching this morning — another glorious day at West Philly High — and a kid asks me if I can get to myspace on my computer. I think he assumed that I had a broadband card (I didn’t) because the School District has blocked myspace.com.

It turns out he was using myspace as a file server, as a way of keeping files (including those for my class) and was now unable to download the paper. I think the smart folks downtown and most adults see these “social networks” as counter to the academic mission but here was a kid using it appropriately only to be unable to access his work.